Marva Collins' Dynamic Process of Control and Value Appraisals

    Marva Collins' stories as an influential educator present the dynamic process of how she perceived control and value in her teaching in different phases of her education career. What fuels a revolution? In the world of education, we often point to curriculum, funding, or policy. But the story of Marva Collins, who transformed the lives of many "unteachable" students on Chicago's West Side, suggests the real fuel is the fundamental human need for agency. By analyzing her journey through the lens of the Control-Value Theory (CVT), we can see how her superhuman motivation was not a mystery, but a predictable outcome of her psychological appraisals.


    Control-Value Theory posits that our emotions and motivations are not random; they are ignited by our appraisals of two key things:

  • Perceived Control: Our belief in our ability to influence activities and outcomes. (Can I do this?)

  • Perceived Value: The subjective importance we assign to those activities and outcomes. (Why does this matter?)

    The dynamic interplay between these two constructs determines whether we feel hopeful or hopeless, proud or ashamed, and whether we are motivated to push forward or give up. Marva Collins’s career is a perfect case study, cleaving neatly into two distinct eras defined by these appraisals.


Phase 1: The Public School Teacher – High Value, Low Control

    As a teacher in the Chicago public school system, Marva Collins’s perceived value was high. She saw the innate potential and brilliance in every child, even though they are in disadvantaged positions. She valued their intellect, their futures, and their right to a rigorous, classical education. However, her perceived control was crushed because the bureaucratic system was designed for compliance, not excellence. She had little say over the watered-down curriculum, the slow pace of instruction, or the culture of low expectations that surrounded her. The extrinsic conditions were working against her values.

    According to CVT, this combination of high value coupled with low control will lead to intense frustration and anger. Collins was not angry at the children, but at the system that failed them. Crucially, in CVT, these negative, activating emotions can fuel motivation to change one's circumstances. However, her frustration was not an endpoint. It was the propellant that motivated her to leave the system and create her own.


Phase 2: The Founder of Westside Prep – Aligned Control, Unleashed Motivation

    The founding of Westside Preparatory School was the masterstroke that realigned Collins's universe of control and value. Her perceived value remained high, but now, her perceived control finally matched it. She now had total agency. She had control over the curriculum, the pedagogy, and the environment in her teaching. She could directly enact the methods she valued.

    This new alignment of high value supported by high control fundamentally transformed her emotional and motivational landscape, as CVT would predict. So her primary emotions became pride, enjoyment, and hope. She took pride in her students' rapid progress, a pride rooted in the direct causal link between her actions and their outcomes. She exhibited a deep, abiding enjoyment in teaching because every lesson was a manifestation of her core values. This positive emotional state created a powerful feedback loop of intrinsic motivation, sustaining her through immense challenges.


Conclusion

    Marva Collins’s legacy is a powerful testament to a central tenet of Control-Value Theory. She proved that by creating an environment where high value is met with genuine agency, we can unlock the profound emotions that drive not just learning, but transformation.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Marva Collins's Self-Efficacy and How She Developed Her Students' Self-Efficacy

Image
     Self-efficacy , which refers to an individual's belief in their own capacity to execute behaviors necessary to produce specific performance attainments , has been examined to be a meaningful predictor of people's success. In this post, we utilize theories of self-efficacy to understand  Marva Collins's  foundation of her own belief and how she  fostered her students' self-efficacy and achievement.  The Sources of Marva's Self-Efficacy      Marva Collins's powerful sense of self-efficacy was built in her childhood when her grandmother taught her how to read before school age, and her father consistently encouraged her to break the discrimination towards Black people and establish her career. Identified by Albert Bandura and other psychologists, the four key sources are previous  mastery experiences ,  observations of similar others performing the same behavior ,  verbal persuasion  from others, and  emotional...
Read more

Marva Collins's Emotional Appraisals in the Process of Building Her School

Image
After moving from her hometown, Alabama, to Chicago, Marva Collins worked as a teacher at a public elementary school in Chicago. It was here that she encountered the widespread  neglect and low expectations placed on Black and low-income students, and therefore, she was determined to establish her own school (Westside Preparatory School) and apply her teaching methods.  In this post, we’ll dissect Marva Collins’s emotional journey as depicted in the 1981 film  The Marva Collins Story and her book Marva Collins' Way. We will  trace her initial frustration, her determined reappraisals during struggle, and her ultimate goal validation to reveal how her inner dialogue built an educational revolution. Movie: The Marva Collins Story Before Building Her School: The Appraisals of Frustration That Forged her Goal Marva’s initial appraisals as a teacher in the Chicago public school system gave rise to her frustration and anger towards conventional education. Her primary...
Read more

Marva Collins: Her Revolutionized Motivations for the "Unteachable" Kids

Image
  Born on August 31, 1936, in Monroeville, Alabama, Marva Collins was a pioneering American educator.  She earned a Bachelor's degree in Secretarial Sciences from Clark College (now Clark Atlanta University). After moving to Chicago, she became a highly effective medical secretary before fulfilling her dream to teach, eventually spending 14 years in the Chicago Public Schools system.   In the 1970s, Chicago's public schools were widely considered to be  in a state of crisis. Classrooms were overcrowded, resources were thin, and a pervasive culture of low expectations plagued the system. Specifically, the children from low-income, predominantly Black neighborhoods were often mislabeled as "learning disabled," "disadvantaged," or "unteachable," "incapable of high achievement." However, it was Marva Collins who was brave enough to declare a radical idea: the problem was not the children; it was the teaching. With a firm belief in students...
Read more